Press Freedom Campaign
#FreeHKJournalists
Since the introduction of the National Security Law in Hong Kong in June 2020, 18 journalists have been arrested and 3 news publications have been forced to close in six months’ time.
The Hong Kong authorities have accused pro-democracy news publications who are independently owned and report the news without fear or favour of distributing “seditious” materials, as they attempt to stamp out any news publications that differ from the Chinese Communist Party’s official line.
RTHK, Hong Kong’s Public Broadcaster, has been reorganised and the former Deputy Secretary of Home Affairs, Patrick Li, was appointed head of broadcasting for the public broadcaster in February 2021. In post he has cancelled news programs critical of the Hong Kong Government, removed online content over a year old, and gave the Hong Kong Chief Executive her own show, leading to mass resignations of journalists.
11 former Apple Daily journalists have been arrested under the National Security Law for “collusion with foreign forces” and await trial with the possibility that they could face upwards to ten years in jail. The Hong Kong Police has confirmed it has a “wanted list” of journalists who they will arrest if they attempt to leave the city. As arrests of journalists continues and pressure from the government escalates, more than 11 media platforms including the prominent Stand News and Citizen News ceased operations and according to Bloomberg Hong Kong civil society has lost 1,585 jobs.
Given Carrie Lam’s announcement of her intention to introduce Article 23 national security legislation and a so-called “fake news” law, the remaining local news publications and journalists stand on the brink.
Responding to the ongoing crackdown on a free press in Hong Kong, Hong Kong Watch launches its global press freedom campaign to support local journalists in Hong Kong. As part of its campaign, Hong Kong Watch calls on:
Lawmakers to spotlight Hong Kong journalists currently in jail for the “crime” of reporting the news and call on the Hong Kong Government to release the former Apple Daily and Stand News journalists in police custody awaiting trial.
Like-minded governments to issue emergency travel documents and visas for journalists at risk of arrest as part of the ongoing crackdown.
Like-minded governments to consider punitive measures to pressure the Hong Kong Government to recommit to upholding the Basic Law which guarantees a free press, including targeted Magnitsky sanctions.
Support from Lord Patten, international politicians and veteran journalists for the campaign
Lord Patten of Barnes, Hong Kong Watch Patron and the last UK Governor of Hong Kong
“Dictatorships, from soft authoritarianism to hardline totalitarianism, hate a free press; or to be more precise they are terrified of a free press.
They are frightened of being held to account by public opinion informed by the media which tells the public what is happening. One of Hong Kong's freedoms, guaranteed in the Joint Declaration and the Basic Law and cherished by the community, was freedom of speech and freedom of the press. The communist party in Beijing and its Quisling supporters in Hong Kong are intent on dismantling the free press there. They have raided newspaper offices. They have imprisoned journalists. They have frozen the assets of privately owned media outlets. They have done all that they can to prevent journalists telling the people of Hong Kong and the world outside what is happening in this once free city. Anyone who contradicts this should ask the Journalists Association in Hong Kong what is happening or listen to all those organisations around the world which seek to defend free speech.
For Xi Jinping, Carrie Lam and their sidekicks, journalism is apparently the same as subversion. We must all continue to call out this appalling assault on liberty. One day Hong Kong will once again have newspapers and broadcasters who can tell the truth about what is happening without fear of incarceration.”
Pat Toomey, US Senator
“Between Beijing’s crackdowns on free press, free speech, and the rule of law, it’s clear the Chinese Communist Party completely abrogated its own commitments to Hong Kong. As the world’s leading defender of democratic values and individual liberties, the U.S. must work with our allies to hold those responsible accountable and demand the CCP restore the autonomy Hong Kong was promised.”
Jenny Kwan MP, Canadian Member of Parliament
“The Hong Kong Basic Law is unequivocal in stating that Hong Kong residents shall have freedom of speech, of the press and of publication. The government of Hong Kong needs to adhere to its constitution and release the journalists that are being turned into political prisoners."
Miriam Lexmann MEP, Member of the European Parliament
“Independent journalism is a fundamental part of any free society. The destruction of media freedom in Hong Kong highlights the wide scale assault on the city's freedom's by the PRC and the Hong Kong SAR.
I welcome Hong Kong Watch's campaign, which mirrors the latest urgency resolution on the continued violations of fundamental freedoms in Hong Kong, in which the European Parliament once again deplored these moves and, among other measures, called for emergency visas for journalists and those responsible to be sanctioned under the EU's Magnitsky Act.”
Frank Schwabe MP, German Member of Parliament
"Questions of human rights are not internal affairs of states, but are protected by international conventions and, in this respect, are also the subject of worldwide publicity. I am concerned to see how the Chinese central government has been intervening massively in Hong Kong at least since the passing of the "National Security Law" and disregarding individual fundamental rights such as freedom of the press and freedom of expression, which are elementary for democracy.
In particular, journalists who are critical of the government and pro-democracy are increasingly threatened with repression and even arrest. We have to speak out. And criticize where it is necessary. Because if we don't do that and simply ignore the situation, the violation of human rights on the ground will only get worse. Human rights must apply to everyone. That's why I support Hong Kong Watch's press freedom campaign. It is good that such campaigns exist. They are essential in the fight for democracy."
Stephen Vines, Former Hong Kong journalist
“Like all authoritarian regimes the government in Hong Kong is keen to operate without scrutiny and to avoid its excesses being exposed. This is why the once free and largely uninhibited local media has been brought under control delivering yet another body blow to Hong Kong's way of life. And this is also why this campaign is important because the suppression of freedom of expression needs to be documented and laid bare for all to see.”
Notable cases of journalists targeted by the Hong Kong authorities
Arrested journalists from Apple Daily
Jimmy Lai
Jimmy Lai, born 8 December 1947 (age 74), is a Hong Kong activist and pro-democracy advocate. He founded Next Digital, the largest listed media company in Hong Kong, and Apple Daily, a newspaper that was willing to criticise the Chinese regime and had covered the pro-democracy protests that was since discontinued in May 2021. He once described the National Security Law to be a “death knell for Hong Kong” that “will supersede or destroy our rule of law and destroy our international financial status.” He was also a frequent visitor to Washington, where he met officials, including former US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, prompting Beijing to label him a “traitor.” Lai was awarded the “Freedom of Press” Award by Reporters Without Borders in December 2020.
Charges and Sentences
On 28 February 2020, Lai was arrested for two charges of “participating in an unauthorised assembly” on 18 August 2019 and 31 August 2019 respectively, and for allegedly intimidating an Oriental Daily reporter after the reporter took pictures of him in 2017. On 3 September 2020, Lai was found not guilty of the Oriental Daily criminal intimidation charge. On 1 April 2021, Lai was found guilty for the unauthorised assemblies and was sentenced to 14 months in prison on 16 April 2021: he received a 15-month sentence for the first charge, reduced by 3 months in mitigation, and an 8-month sentence for the second charge, of which he will serve only 2. District Court Judge Amanda Woodcock said even though the 18 August assembly was peaceful there was a "latent risk of possible violence" and that a deterrent sentence and "immediate imprisonment" was appropriate.
On 18 April 2020, Lai was arrested for “incitement to knowingly take part in an unauthorized assembly” on 1 October 2019. He was one of the 15 high-profile pro-democracy figures arrested, including former chairs of the Democratic Party Martin Lee and Albert Ho. On 28 May 2021, he was given a new prison sentence of 14 months.
On June 11 2020, Lai was notified that he would be facing charges for “incitement to knowingly take part in an unauthorized assembly” for a Tiananmen Square vigil on 4 June 2020. The others notified included former legislators Lee Cheuk-yan and Albert Ho Chun-yan. On 1 November 2021, the first day of hearing in the District Court, Lai pleaded not guilty.
On 10 August 2020, Lai was arrested under the National Security Law for "collusion with a foreign country or external elements to endanger national security.” Other Next Digital employees were also arrested and police searched the homes of both Lai and his son. On the same day, 200 Hong Kong police officers proceeded to raid the Apple Daily headquarters and seized around 25 boxes of materials. Lai’s arrest and the raid were considered by former governor Chris Patten as the “most outrageous assault yet on what is left of Hong Kong’s free press.” On 11 December 2020, Lai was formally charged under the National Security Law for allegedly “colluding with a foreign country, or with external forces, to endanger national security”; “conspiring to commit collusion with foreign forces to endanger national security”; and “conspiring to do an act or a series of acts tending and intended to pervert the course of public justice.” The main evidence for the charge consisted of political views he had expressed on Twitter and in media interviews in which he requested foreign governments to impose sanctions on Hong Kong and Chinese officials. On 23 December 2020, Lai was granted bail by the High Court. On 31 December 2020, the Court of Final Appeal ordered Lai back to prison after the Department of Justice appealed his release on bail. On 9 February 2021, the Court of Final Appeal denied Lai’s bail and on 19 February 2021 it rejected a new bail application by Lai with judge Anthea Pang saying that there was not enough evidence Lai would refrain from acts endangering national security if released from prison.
On 2 December 2020, Lai reported to the police station as part of his bail condition for his August 2020 arrest related to the National Security Law violation but was arrested by police for alleged fraud, in that he and two Next Digital executives allegedly violated lease terms for a Next Digital office space. He was detained and denied bail on the fraud charge. On 6 May 2021, prosecutors asked for a judge designated for National Security Law cases to try Lai on his fraud charge, but the application was put on hold as the defence revealed it had yet to examine evidence submitted by the prosecution, prompting to judge to adjourn the case for another hearing ahead of next March’s scheduled trial.
On 16 February 2021, Lai was arrested in Stanley Prison for one count of “conspiracy with a foreign country or with external elements to endanger national security” under the National Security Law and one count of “conspiracy to assist an offender under the Crimes Ordinance.” For the first charge, he was accused of conspiring with other individuals including activists Andy Li and Finn Lau to request foreign countries to impose sanctions against Hong Kong and China between 1 July 2020 and 15 February 2021. For the latter charge, he was accused of conspiring with Li, Lau and others to assist Li’s escape to Taiwan in an attempt to obstruct his arrest and prosecution despite having knowledge or belief that Li had committed indictable crimes. Lai has yet to face trial for the charges, but Li had already pleaded guilty to conspiring with Lai to ask external forces to impose sanctions on Hong Kong and China on 19 August 2021.
Lai has been remanded in jail since 31 December 2020 and is serving a total of 20 months imprisonment.
Cheung Kim-hung
Cheung Kim Hung, the Chief Executive of Next Digital, was arrested on August 10 2020 along with other Next Digital executives for offences including collusion with foreign powers and conspiracy to defraud. They were detained over the subletting of part of Next Digital’s offices to a consulting company, which the government alleged violated the terms of the media company’s land lease. He was arrested again on June 17 2021 during an Apple Daily raid conducted by more than 500 police officers. He was accused of conspiracy to collude with foreign forces along with other executives. He was denied bail in the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts. The first hearing will be held on February 24 in the High Court.
Wong Wai-keung
Wong Wai Keung, the chief administrative officer of Next Digital was arrested on August 10 2020 along with other Next Digital executives for offences including collusion with foreign powers and conspiracy to defraud. They were detained over the subletting of part of Next Digital’s offices to a consulting company, which the government alleged violated the terms of the media company’s land lease.
Royston Chow
Royston Chow, the chief operating officer and chief financial officer of Next Digital Media was arrested on August 10 2020 along with other Next Digital executives for offences including collusion with foreign powers and conspiracy to defraud. They were detained over the subletting of part of Next Digital’s offices to a consulting company, which the government alleged violated the terms of the media company’s land lease. He was arrested again on June 17 2021 during an Apple Daily raid conducted by more than 500 police officers. He was accused of conspiracy to collude with foreign forces along with other executives. He was released on bail on June 18.
Ryan Law Wai-kwong
Ryan Law, the chief editor of Apple Daily, was arrested on June 17 2021 during an Apple Daily raid conducted by more than 500 police officers. Hei was accused of conspiracy to collude with foreign forces along with other executives. He was denied bail in the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts. The first hearing will be held on 24 February in the High Court.
Cheung Chi-wai
Cheung Chi-wai, the platform director of Apple Daily Digital, was arrested on June 17 2021 during an Apple Daily raid conducted by more than 500 police officers. Hei was accused of conspiracy to collude with foreign forces along with other executives. He was released on bail on June 18.
Lam Man-chung
Lam Man-chung, the former executive editor of Apple Daily, was arrested on July 21 2021. His house was searched on the same day. He had resigned from Apple daily after overseeing the publication of the newspaper’s last copy on June 24 2021. The first hearing will be held on 24 February in the High Court Court.
Chan Pui-man
Chan Pui-man, the former associate publisher of Apple Daily was arrested on June 16 2021 along with Next Digital executives and editors and was accused of conspiring with them to ask foreign powers. Chan was released on bail on June 18 after hours of detention. On July 21, police revoked her bail and she has been held in pre-trial detention at the Tai Lam Centre for Women since then. On October 12, Chan and other Next Digital executives appeared at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Court, where their national security cases were adjourned to December 28. She pleaded not guilty. She faced a new charge of conspiracy to publish seditious publications alongside other Next Digital and Apple Daily executives. Her next hearing would be on February 24 2022 at the High Court, where the maximum penalty is life behind bars. On December 29, while she was detained, Chan was arrested on a separate case for being involved in publishing seditious publications for Stand News along with her husband Chung Pui-kuen, who was the editor in chief at Stand News.
Fung Wai-kong
Fung Wai-kong, the former senior editorial writer of Apple Daily, was believed to be leaving Hong Kong for the United Kingdom on June 27 2021 when he was arrested for conspiring to collude with foreign powers. The first hearing will be held on 24 February in the High Court Court.
Yeung Ching-kee
Yeung Ching-kee (also known as Lee Ping), an editorial writer for Apple Daily, was arrested on June 23 2021 for conspiring to collude with foreign powers. The first hearing will be held on 24 February in the High Court Court.
Kith Ng Tat-kong
Kith Ng, the Chief Executive of Next Animation Studio, was arrested on August 10 2020 along with other Next Digital executives for offences including collusion with foreign powers and conspiracy to defraud. They were detained over the subletting of part of Next Digital’s offices to a consulting company, which the government alleged violated the terms of the media company’s land lease.
Arrested journalists at Stand News
Chung Pui-kuen
Chung Pui-kuen, the former chief editor at Stand News, was arrested on December 29 2021 under the Crimes Ordinance for conspiring to publish seditious publications. He was brought to West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts the next day and was denied bail.
Ronson Chan
Ronson Chan Ron Sing was the deputy assignment editor of the now shut down Stand News and is the chairman of the Hong Kong Journalists Association. On December 29 2021, Chan was amongst 6 Stand News senior members and board members who were arrested under the Crimes Ordinance for conspiring to publish seditious publications. Alongside the Stand News newsroom, Chan’s house was raided by the police. He was also taken by police for questioning, but released hours later. Chan is currently unemployed, if he fails to find another job within 3 months, he will not be able to serve as the chairman of HKJA.
Chow Tat-chi
Chow Tat-chi, the former director and ex-chief editor of the science section of Stand News. He was arrested on December 29 2021 under the Crimes Ordinance for conspiring to publish seditious publications. He was released on police bail the next day without charge.
Patrick Lam
Patrick Lam, the former chief editor at Stand News was arrested on December 29 2021 under the Crimes Ordinance for conspiring to publish seditious publications. He did not make an appearance for mention at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Court the next day owing to health reasons. He was denied bail nonetheless.
Other notable arrested journalists
Allan Au Ka Lun
Veteran journalist Allan Au Ka Lun was arrested on 11 April for conspiring to publish seditious materials. Au worked as a senior producer at TVB News and a radio host on RTHK, and was also a columnist for outlets including Stand News and Ming Pao. Au was fired from RTHK in June 2021 amid a government-directed editorial overhaul. Au's arrest was reportedly linked with the Stand News case in which the platform's former editor-in-chief Chung Pui Kuen and former acting chief editor Patrick Lam were arrested and are currently held in custody pending trial under the same charge. Au was released on bail on 11 April night after being detained by the police for over 17 hours. (HKFP)
Choy Yuk-ling
Choy Yuk-ling, also known as Bao Choy, was a video producer who worker at RTHK. She was arrested and charged for violating the Road Traffic Ordinance by giving false statements to obtain vehicle information during research for a documentary on November 2 2020. Her investigative documentary, “7.21: Who Owns the Truth,” was on the violent mob attacks that took place on July 21 2019, at the Yuen Long MTR station, and the police’s handling of that incident. The documentary won Hong Kong’s prestigious Kam Yiu-yu Press Freedom Award. On April 22 2021, Choy was convicted and was fined HK$6000 by the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Court.
Wilson Li
Wilson Li, a freelance journalist from the UK’s ITN and ex-member of the disbanded student group Scholarism, was arrested in connection with the NGO Fight for Freedom, Stand with Hong Kong along with activist Andy Li on 10 August 2020 for collusion with foreign powers. He was released on a HK$20k bail and HK$18k surety, while the police retained his passport, phones, computers and bank cards.